Hot Toddy cocktail with Sherry – Simple Hot Toddy recipe

How to make Hot Toddy cocktail with Sherry

The Hot Toddy cocktail has become a cold-weather staple over the last few hundred years. Int he past used as a cure for the cold, or to heat you up on a frigid winter day, this cocktail checks all the boxes as its approachability and functionality can be enjoyed by any kind of drinker. The Hot Toddy is said to date back to the late 18th Century in British ruled India and is defined as a beverage made of alcoholic liquor with hot water, sugar, and spices. Traditionally made with whisk(e)y (Scotch was the original whisky since that is what the British produced and consumed), this cocktail can be made with your alcohol of choice and given how many wonderful spirits we have access to today, it is worth experimenting to see which Toddy is right for you. For our Toddy, we chose to use oloroso sherry in place of the whisk(e)y as it is bold enough to use in lieu of a spirit yet gives the cocktail a nice layer of complexity. Additionally, by using sherry, we have cut the ABV content by at least half, making this a very good low ABV alternative to the original Hot Toddy.

Which Sherry is best for a Classic Hot Toddy

Although we think oloroso sherry works best in this cocktail, we encourage you to try the other dry, oxidative sherries (amontillado and palo cortado) as the ABV and overall flavor of the sherry is strong enough to cut through the honey, lemon, and spices. A fino or manzanilla sherry could work, but due to how light in flavor they are, you would need to add a little extra sherry to balance out the cocktail.

About Lustau Don Nuño Oloroso

For our Toddy, we chose the Lustau Don Nuño Oloroso as it has a nice presence in the drink and won’t kill your pocketbook either. It is for us the best sherry for a hot toddy cocktail. Since we are diluting this drink with either hot water or hot tea, using a more expensive and overly aged sherry would not be wise as the complexity of the wine will get loss once it is diluted.

Hot Toddy with Sherry Ingredients – Best Hot Toddy recipe with Whisky

  • 1.5oz Lustau Don Nuno Oloroso Sherry
  • .5oz Honey Syrup (3:1 Honey to Hot Water)
  • 6oz Hot Water
  • Warm Coffee Mug
  • Garnish: Lemon Wheel with Cloves

Hot Toddy cocktail Recipe – Step by step how to prepare the “Hot Todd”

  1. Add honey syrup and oloroso sherry to a warm coffee mug
  2. Add 6oz of hot water
  3. Stir ingredients together until the honey is completely dissolved
  4. Garnish with the lemon wedge with cloves in it

Tips for Hot Toddy with sherry Cocktail

If you’re feeling adventurous, try the cocktail with equal parts sherry and a spirit of your choice. Perhaps oloroso and scotch whisky? This will increase the ABV as well as add a little extra flavor to your tasty concoction.

Hot Toddy Variations

Hot Toddy with Brandy de Jerez

  1. 1.5oz Lustau Brandy de Jerez Solera Gran Reserva
  2. .5oz Forest Honey Syrup
  3. 6oz Hot Water
  4. Garnish: Lemon Wheel with Cloves

Hot Toddy with Bourbon

  1. 1.5oz Bourbon
  2. .5oz Forest Honey Syrup
  3. 6oz Hot Water
  4. Garnish: Lemon Wheel with Cloves

Hot Toddy with Rum

  1. 1.5oz Dark Rum
  2. .5oz Clover Honey Syrup
  3. 6oz Hot Water
  4. Garnish: Lemon Wheel and Grated Nutmeg

Hot Toddy with Tea

  1. 1.5oz Blended Scotch Whisky
  2. .5oz Manuka Honey Syrup
  3. 6oz Black Tea
  4. Garnish: Lemon Wheel and Cardamom Pods

Hot Toddy with Apple Cider

  1. 1.5oz Apple Cider
  2. .5oz Orange Blossom Honey Syrup
  3. 6oz Hot Water
  4. Garnish: Lemon Wheel and Cinnamon Stick


What alcohol is in a hot toddy?

Whisk(e)y is traditionally used in a Hot Toddy but use whatever spirit you’d like!

How long does it take to prepare a hot toddy?

The Hot Toddy is a simple drink to make and takes as long as water takes to boil.

What is the best whisky for a hot toddy?

Typically, Scotch or Bourbon are used to make a Toddy, but whatever whisk(e)y you like to consume will work nicely.

Hot Toddy best with cold or hot weather?

Since this is a hot drink, most people consume this during the colder months of the year. That being said, If you need to warm yourself up feel free to have a Toddy whenever it suits you.

Cocktail by Steven Dragun, Lustau Craft Spirits Consultant. @misterdragun View more cocktail from Steven here

Get the latest news about Sherry in your inbox!

0 comments on “Hot Toddy cocktail with Sherry – Simple Hot Toddy recipeAdd yours →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.